fbpx

The Commodification of Women: From Mais Hamdan to Ramez Galal

Myriam Sweidan
Lebanese Journalist
April 29, 2020
Both public opinion and the authorities denounced Mais Hamdan’s commercial based on the principle that states that it is unacceptable for a woman to admire a man’s body, whereas Ramez Galal's offensive behavior towards his guest, describing her as "divorced", went unnoticed.

The Ramadan season arrives alongside an abundance of television productions that also bring with them many surprises. The television dramas dedicated to this season seem to have shared features, including humiliating women, as well as serving to validate and maintain the masculinist approaches through the models presented in the series or commercials.

Recently, Egyptian media witnessed a glaring irony, as the Egyptian authorities cancelled the TV commercial for “Cottonil” underwear, featuring Mais Hamdan, because of the public debate it stirred, as many considered it “indecent”, only three days after it was broadcast over satellite channels during the month of Ramadan.

The Egyptian actress Mais Hamdan appears in a commercial singing to her neighbour, admiring his walk, style and underwear. This scene from the commercial of the company “Cottonil”, owned by the Syrian businessman Basil Smakia, raised a huge debate from the minute it was broadcast. Egyptians considered it “indecent”, and demanded that the Parliament intervene to ban it

Mais Hamdan in the Cottonil Television Advertisement

This commercial could have been considered normal, but the paradox of a woman appreciating a man’s body and not the other way around brought with it a huge wave of controversy, regardless of the commercial’s quality; the idea that amounted to so much rage among the public and the authorities was that it was unacceptable for a woman to express her admiration of a man’s body.

Therefore, the Egyptian Consumer Protection Agency banned the commercial, as it was “offensive to public taste and did not respect the traditions of the society”.

The Agency said that it decided to “suspend the broadcast of the commercial as it was clearly violating personal dignity, community standards, the law of consumer protection and the standard specifications of advertising goods and services.”

This commercial could have been considered normal, but the paradox of a woman appreciating a man’s body and not the other way around brought with it a huge wave of controversy

Cottonil announced that they will “totally commit to the decision, and concede to the Agency’s opinion, to preserve the values of the Egyptian society and its traditions,” according to their statement.

Things however, did not stop at that point, and escalated further as at least two parliament members applied for an urgent briefing to punish the company for an ‘outrage of modesty’ in addition to another request to the Prime Minister and the Ministry of Mass Media, to prohibit the broadcast of such indecent commercials on TV. They also requested that the actress be punished, leading her to delete the commercial from her social media accounts and apologize. This apology has been repeated and witnessed among several actresses and female public figures, who were forced by means of social and legal restrictions to retreat, so that they are able to continue working and appearing in the public virtual sphere.

The irony here was that the National Council for Women also denounced the commercial, considering it degrading to the Egyptian woman, and detrimental to her role in society, while the same council turned a blind eye to various insults targeting women in other media programs, the most recent of which was the yearly program presented by actor Ramez Galal.

The program ‘Ramez is Legally Insane!’ was not free from criticism this season, as a number of lawyers submitted demands to stop broadcasting the program, after the first episode, for spreading the culture of violence.

The program is based on the notion of ‘pranks’ on celebrities and stars, and has been airing for years in different versions. This year’s version was frought with sadism and humiliation, whereby his guest is strapped to a chair and subjected to different forms of torture, like electric shocks, submerging in water, physical and psychological harm, inspired by the famous horror movie series, SAW,with Ramez’s sarcastic tone in the background. This is a clear violation of the basic standards of arts and creativity and innovation, which will inevitably lead to encouraging viewers, especially teenagers and children, to imitate these acts of violence.

But the program exceeded that by far, from the very first episode, where actress Ghada Adel was the guest; the content was clearly misogynistic, incredibly offensive and humiliating to the Egyptian woman, and a striking example of using the media’s power to reinforce gender inequality.

Ghada Adel on “Ramez is Legally Insane”

The episode started by Galal describing his guest as “divorced,” when he says, “She was our guest once before, but that was when she was married, things were difficult back then, but now, things have changed, she’s now divorced and free, no longer having to breastfeed or burp the babies, she can now dance to pop music, and be free to do whatever she wants.”

In addition to this were the misogynistic implications by the presenter, representing in the behind the scenes camera capturing and focusing on the details of his guest’s body while she was attaching her microphone onto herself, and preparing to shoot the episode. He also described her as a ‘rabbit’, because she had five children.

The program is based on the practice of sadism and humiliation, as the guest is bound to a chair and is tortured in a “comedic” manner.

In this context, Alia Awada, a feminist and human rights activist, explains that what is occuring should be linked to two main structures: first, the media and advertising empire, which makes use of women’s bodies to market their goods, and secondly, the values and traditions system which is used as an appointed guardian on women’s bodies.

As for the ‘Ramez is Legally Insane!’ program, the inappropriate content and vulgarity were not surprising for Awadah, as the program has been aired on one of the most famous media groups in the Arab world, the MBC Group, which seeks this type of content because it often attracts many viewers, especially during Ramadan, the peak season for commercials. She added, “In addition to the indecent content, the program reinforces the culture of guardianship over women, by making them look like weak victims facing masculinism, as well as sustaining a dangerous commodificationist and stereotypical language.”

Awada sees that women in Arab societies are finally exhibiting a rebellion against stereotypes, but still they are often faced with impossible social coercion.

Perhaps this is what happened with Mais Hamdan in her commercial, as the Egyptian public rejected the image of the woman who was courting a man, as an unfamiliar scene, and a different one from the typical image the media and social systems portray of the Arab woman.

الأكثر قراءة

Share on facebook
Share on twitter
Share on whatsapp
Share on email

Related articles

Vicken Cheterian
Azerbaijan’s aim is to change the format of negotiations by including Turkey…Turkey is part of the Karabakh conflict since its early stages, not only diplomatically and by its implication in imposing a blockade against Armenia, but also militarily.
Dr. Maitrayee Mukhopadhyay
The question before us is not whether the practice of caste has divine origins or what it was before colonialism but what it became in the present.
Marie Melham and Ahmad Haj Hamdo
The laws in Turkey, alongside the Syrian refugee women’s ignorance of what their rights are, has caused them to face many problems. This report highlights the stories of the women caught between the Syrian and Turkish laws.
Khaled Suleiman- Iraqi writer and journalist
The death of forests due to these fires releases more carbon dioxide and heat not only in Syria and Lebanon, but also throughout the entire region, because Mediterranean forests have a giant climatic effect in terms of humidity, rain and winds on the entire interior regions of the southern Mediterranean. Hence, the greenhouse gases that were absorbed by the trees will eventually find their way into our lungs, even after the fires subside.
Mizer Kamal
The war was over in Mosul, but other battles were still unfolding. The returnees to the old Iraqi city are still dealing with poverty and disease, and with unidentified bodies buried under the rubble of demolished and mined buildings. Their recovery has become a daily occurrence, no longer newsworthy.
Youmna Al-Kadi
“I saw Owais on the ground, soaked in his own blood, and his father was next to him, unable to stand on his feet.” Here is the story of Owais, the man who was killed by the Egyptian police in front of his own father.
Share on facebook
Share on twitter
Share on whatsapp
Share on email
لتصلكم نشرة درج الى بريدكم الالكتروني